A Separate Peace
What was the irony in seeing Finny being carried by others??
cht. 12
cht. 12
The scene after Finny's accident is very odd; with no mention of him either speaking or moving, it is like he is already dead. This is the final break between Finny and Gene; Gene stays at the edge of the crowd while Finny is in the center, and there doesn't seem to be any contact between them, or any recognition on Finny's part either. Gene notes a difference in Finny's look too; he says the sight of Finny being carried off is like that of "some tragic and exalted personage, a stricken pontiff." Finny's position is finally reversed, as he truly becomes helpless, and his friend is too shocked to step in and help him out. This comparison does not bode well for Finny's recovery; in Gene's language, there is a sense that things are coming to an end that foreshadows Finny's fate. This is ironic because Finny always saw Gene as "an extension of himself" (171). Gene, however, had never felt the same way.
http://www.gradesaver.com/a-separate-peace/study-guide/summary-chapters-12-13