Great Expectations
What do we learn at the end of Chapter XLII (42) that shines a new light on Provis’ and Miss Havisham’s stories? How does this affect your impression of Miss Havisham? Provis? Compeyson?
Chapter 42
Chapter 42
Herbert passes a note to Pip: "Young Havisham's name was Arthur. Compeyson is the man who professed to be Miss Havisham's lover."
Magwitch hates Compeyson with a self-sacrificing vengeance, and yet the reason for his hatred -- that Compeyson was the mastermind behind the crimes yet received less of a sentence -- is tied to his sacrifice for Pip. Compeyson got a lighter sentence because he was considered by society to be a gentleman. So Magwitch sets out on a life of sacrifice to provide the same advantages for Pip. Magwitch both hates this societal label and accepts it, as is demonstrated by his constant reference to himself as "low." Indeed, Dickens seems to hint that Magwitch may have been a much different man if people had not told him since a young age that he would come to no good. And yet he wants to exploit the societal labeling by promoting Young Pip into gentlemanhood.
Magwitch, a sympathetic character, is a reflection of what Pip, or any of us, could become if we take societal labels to heart.