Will it be worse to suffer the consequences of making poor choices or not to be able to choose at all? Why?

Not having the ability to choose would be far worse than making the wrong choice...... in my opinion. Having our lives drawn our for us, never deviating from what we're "allowed" to do would be not only boring.... it would be oppressive. We learn from mistakes, we express ourselves through decisions, debates, and our choices..... right or wrong are ours to make. What is your opinion?