If you were the one in Harry's position, what would you have done? Would you have returned the book to the teachers, or would you have kept it? Why or why not?

Well if I were in Harry's situation, I would definitely return the book. Something tells me in that book it's dangerous and it can kill you. So I would 110% all the way, return the book to a teacher. Maybe they can contain it or something.

i would have done the wright thing and thats to return the bok to the treachers

I definitely agree with Bastiaan and Brendan. I would have returned it because you don't know what might happen to you if you don't turn the book to the teachers. I think Hermione and Ron thought Harry was acting a little suspicious because of a book. I remember in the movie when Harry and Ron arrived late for Horace Slughorn's potions class, Horace turns to them and says to go grab a book from the cabinet. Harry and Ron search for the Potions books and then their eyes both fall on one................

I probably would have kept it but then again, sometimes things aren't as safe as you think they are.

Returning it would be the best bet because if you don't, you could put yourself, your teachers, your classmates, and the school in terrible danger. Returning the book would be the right thing to do. Not keep it.

I would have kept it. Sounds like a cool book to me.

Why would you have kept it Cullen? Don't you realize that it's a terrible fate for young Mr. Potter?

Yes we know it's a terrible fate for Harry, Brendan. We realized that, like, a split second before you did, I think. Never mind.