Genre
Fiction
Setting and Context
The novel is primarily set in two places: a luxurious Caribbean resort on the fictional island of Saint X and later in New York City.
Narrator and Point of View
The novel is primarily narrated from the third-person limited point of view, mainly through the perspective of Claire (formerly Emily), Alison's younger sister.
Tone and Mood
The tone of the novel is serious and introspective, while the mood fluctuates between suspenseful, melancholic, and contemplative.
Protagonist and Antagonist
The protagonist of the novel is Claire, who grapples with the loss of her sister and tries to find answers to the mystery of her death. However, there isn't a clear antagonist in the conventional sense.
Major Conflict
The central conflict in the novel revolves around Claire's struggle to cope with her sister's mysterious death and her quest to uncover the truth about what happened to Alison.
Climax
The climax occurs when Claire finally confronts Clive Richardson, the man she believes might be responsible for her sister's death. This leads to an emotional outburst and the unraveling of long-suppressed feelings and realizations.
Foreshadowing
Alison's careless behavior and her fascination with the dangerous "off-limits" areas of the island hint at her impending tragedy.
Understatement
Claire's initial handling of her sister's death is an example of understatement. Initially, she describes her sister's death merely as "tragic," which doesn't truly encapsulate the magnitude of her feelings of loss, confusion, and grief.
Allusions
There are allusions to pop culture, religion, and literary works throughout the novel.
Imagery
The descriptions of the Caribbean island, its clear waters, and lush greenery paint a vivid picture of paradise which contrasts sharply with the grim reality of Alison's death.
Paradox
The novel presents the paradox of the "paradise" Saint X appears to be and the "hell" it turns into after Alison's death. The resort is a place of beauty, relaxation, luxury, tragedy, disparity, and hidden socio-economic divides.
Parallelism
Parallelism is used in the novel through the mirroring experiences of Claire and Alison. Both sisters experience being outsiders: Alison is an enigmatic figure who doesn't fit the stereotypical mold, and Claire is perpetually in her older sister's shadow, feeling like an outsider in her own life.
Metonymy and Synecdoche
N/A
Personification
Schaitkin personifies grief and loss throughout the novel. For example, Claire's grief over her sister's death is described as an ever-present entity, lurking and dictating her actions and decisions.