The Gift of the Magi and Other Stories Lesson Plan

Why do you think Ben Price lets Jimmy go free at the end of "A Retrieved Reformation"? Do you agree with his choice? Why or why not? How does this ending connect to the title of the story?

In considering their positions, students should consider the many elements included by Henry in the story, for instance, how far Ben Price has traveled to get to Elmore, how long he has been tracking Jimmy Valentine, or how much emotional investment he has in Jimmy's case. They might also consider the historical context of the story, and how law enforcement was conducted within that context. Students may discuss not only whether they agree with Ben Price but whether they think his...