Essay Questions

How does Religious allusion back Weber’s argument regarding ‘the real relationship between ethics and politics?” - “The Profession and Vocation of Politics”

Weber elucidates, “The commandment of the Gospel is unconditional and unambiguous-give all thou hast’-everything absolutely. The politician will say that this is an excessive and socially meaningless demand if it is not made to apply to everybody, which means taxation, expropriation by taxation, confiscation, in other words, coercion and order applied to all…The ethical commandment disregards such questions completely- that is its essence. The same applies to the injunction to ‘turn the other cheek!’…This is the heart of the matter: it is necessary to be a saint in all things, or at least one must want to be one, one must live like Jesus, the Apostles, Saint Francis and the men of that kind; then this type of ethic becomes meaningful and expresses a kind of dignity.” Weber contends that politicians are not above ethics, politics should endeavor to endorse decency in their accomplishments; they are not anticipated to construe and apply the Bible plainly though. Politicians who sponsor ethics function as idyllic samples of fabricating a sublime state where leaders substantially truncate depravities. Being a politician is not an endorsement to trespass ethics frantically.

Describe Weber’s foremost rhetorical appeal in “The Nation State and Economic Policy”.

Appeal to Logos: Weber confirms, “we only have at our disposal the figures from 1871 to 1885 as a basis for observing the population shifts in individual parishes, and these figures allow us to perceive only the indistinct beginnings of a trend.” Weber’s avowals are based on steadfast statistical archives. The expositions that Weber makes are equal to a synthesis of the statistics outlined in the census annals. The citation of such requisite statistics reinforces Weber’s deductions vis-à-vis repercussions of economic strategies.