Citizenfour Laura Poitras

Citizenfour is a 2014 documentary film directed by Laura Poitras, concerning Edward Snowden and the NSA spying scandal. The film had its US premiere on October 10, 2014, at the New York Film Festival and its UK premiere on October 17, 2014, at the BFI London Film Festival. The film features Snowden and Glenn Greenwald, and was co-produced by Poitras, Mathilde Bonnefoy, and Dirk Wilutzky, with Steven Soderbergh and others serving as executive producers. Citizenfour received critical acclaim upon release, and was the recipient of numerous accolades, including Best Documentary Feature at the 87th Academy Awards. This film is the third part to a 9/11 trilogy following My Country, My Country (2006) and The Oath (2010).

In January 2013, Laura Poitras, an American documentary film director/producer who had been working for several years on a film about monitoring programs in the United States that were the result of the September 11 attacks, receives an encrypted e-mail from a stranger who calls himself "Citizen Four."[5] (Per a 2014 Vice article featuring Poitras, Snowden chose this codename as a nod to three NSA whistleblowers who came before him: Bill Binney, J. Kirk Wiebe, and Thomas Drake.[6]) In Snowden's initial message to Poitras, he offers her inside information about illegal wiretapping practices of the US National Security Agency (NSA) and other intelligence agencies. In June 2013, accompanied by columnist Glenn Greenwald and The Guardian intelligence reporter Ewen MacAskill,[7] she travels to Hong Kong with her camera for the first meeting with "Citizenfour" in a hotel, who reveals himself as Edward Snowden. Scenes of their meeting take place in Snowden's hotel room, where he maintains his privacy. Shots of Snowden in his bed, in front of his mirror and of the hotel from a distance form the character of Snowden as a trapped political agent.[8]

After four days of interviews, on June 9, Snowden's identity is made public at his request. As media outlets begin to discover his location at the Mira Hotel, Snowden moves into Poitras's room in an attempt to elude phone calls made to his room. Facing potential extradition and prosecution in the United States, Snowden schedules a meeting with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and applies for refugee status. After Poitras believes she is being followed, she leaves Hong Kong for Berlin, Germany.

On June 21, the US government requests the Hong Kong government extradite Snowden. Snowden manages to depart from Hong Kong, but his US passport is cancelled before he can connect to Havana, stranding him in the Sheremetyevo International Airport in Moscow for 40 days. On August 1, 2013, the Russian government grants Snowden temporary asylum for a period of one year.[9] Meanwhile, Greenwald returns to his home in Rio de Janeiro and speaks publicly about United States's utilization of NSA programs for foreign surveillance. Greenwald and Poitras maintain a correspondence wherein they both express reluctance to return to the United States.

Throughout, the film offers smaller vignettes that precede and follow Snowden's Hong Kong interviews, including William Binney speaking about NSA programs, and eventually testifying before the German Parliament regarding NSA spying in Germany.

The film closes with Greenwald, Snowden and Poitras meeting once again, this time in Russia. Greenwald and Snowden discuss new emerging details on US intelligence programs, careful to only write down and not speak critical pieces of information. Greenwald tears these documents creating a pile of scraps, before slowly removing them from the table.

• Edward Snowden
• Glenn Greenwald
• Laura Poitras
• Ewen MacAskill
• Jacob Appelbaum
• William Binney
• Julian Assange
• Ladar Levison
• Jeremy Scahill
• Sarah Harrison

Born on June 21, 1983, in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, Edward Snowden first became involved with the United States government upon his enrollment in the Army Reserves in the spring of 2004.[10] Snowden claims to have left the program after a few months because he broke his legs in a training accident while a US House of Representatives report claims he had shin splints.[11] He then began working for the CIA in 2006 and was stationed with diplomatic cover at the embassy in Geneva, Switzerland in 2007. After nearly three years with the agency, Snowden resigned his position in February 2009 in order to begin working for a contractor with Dell for the NSA.

It was at this point in his career that Snowden could sense that his views were changing; "I watched as Obama advanced the very policies that I thought would be reined in ... [The NSA] are intent on making every conversation and every form of behaviour in the world known to them".[12] In 2012, Snowden was reassigned from Yokota base in Japan to the Kunia Operations Center in Honolulu, Hawaii, working for Dell before serving as a consultant to Booz Allen Hamilton.[13] As an "infrastructure analyst" at the National Threat Operations Center, he monitored internet communication.[14]

In his own words, the longer he continued to work for the NSA, the more he "worked in to resist" his own feelings regarding the various programs in place at the agency.[15] He had served at the Hawaiian base for approximately 15 months prior to leaving the United States with thousands of classified documents. In 2020, Snowden is still living in exile in Russia and conducted three interviews, one with John Oliver on Last Week Tonight in April 2015 - one with NPR's Fresh Air segment[16] and one with Wired[17] prior to the release of his autobiography Permanent Record on September 12, 2019.

By 2012, Poitras had begun work on the third film in her 9/11 trilogy (My Country, My Country (2006) and The Oath (2010)), which she intended to focus broadly on the topic of domestic surveillance for which she interviewed Assange, Greenwald, Binney, and Appelbaum.[18] She was first contacted by Snowden in January 2013 after he was unable to establish encrypted communications with Greenwald.[19][20] She flew to Hong Kong in late May 2013, where, over the course of eight days, she filmed Snowden in his hotel room[18] at the Mira Hotel in Hong Kong. Later, she traveled to Moscow where she filmed a second interview with Snowden conducted by Greenwald.

Production company Praxis Films was involved in the production of the documentary. The film was distributed by RADIUS TWC in the US,[21] BRITDOC Foundation and Artificial Eye in the UK[22] and Piffl Media in Germany. The broadcast rights for television were obtained by Channel 4 (United Kingdom), HBO Documentary Films (USA) and Norddeutscher Rundfunk (Germany).

The soundtrack consists of portions of the Nine Inch Nails album Ghosts I–IV, which was released under a Creative Commons license (BY-NC-SA) in 2008.

Security measures

Poitras took many security precautions related to the film, described by military writer Peter Maass among others.[23] She moved to Berlin, Germany[24] after being detained repeatedly at border controls when entering the US.[23] She edited the film in Germany after flying directly there from Hong Kong with the Snowden footage, to prevent the FBI from showing up with a search warrant for her hard drives. All the film footage is kept on encrypted drives with multiple levels of nested protection.[25] The computer she uses for reading sensitive documents is separated from the internet by an air gap. Greenwald credited her with a "complete expert level of understanding of how to do a story like this with total technical and operational safety". Maass called Poitras's security skills "particularly vital — and far from the journalistic norm — in an era of pervasive government spying", and quotes Snowden stating that "[i]n the wake of this year's disclosure, it should be clear that unencrypted journalist-source communication is unforgivably reckless."[23]

Producer Bonnefoy has also discussed the encrypted workflow used in making the film, adding "if we have a conversation that's particularly confidential, we'll move the electronics out of the room, or we'll just meet somewhere outside of the editing room, without our phones."[26]

The Film Society of Lincoln Center (which selects films for the New York Film Festival) reported[27] that Poitras changed the location of the initial screening for the NYFF's selection committee several times, in case someone was tracking her movements. The committee was shown a rough cut that had sensitive material redacted, and the NYFF "had to keep the movie's inclusion in the festival under wraps until mid-September" and it was "kept out of festival schedules and documents until we could talk about it openly". The last-minute inclusion in the festival's main slate was an unprecedented event for the NYFF,[28] and "tickets for both screenings sold out within just a few hours".[27]

The film's ending credits unusually[25] name several free software projects and security tools, without which "this film would not be possible". The programs named include Tor, Tails, Debian GNU/Linux, Off-the-Record Messaging, the GNU Privacy Guard, Truecrypt, and SecureDrop. In October 2014, the Electronic Frontier Foundation published an informational page about the software credited in the film,[29] and, in November 2015, Poitras was prominently featured in a Tor fund-raising campaign.[30]

The international film premiere took place on October 10, 2014, in the United States at the New York Film Festival. In Europe, the documentary was shown for the first time on October 17 at the BFI London Film Festival. The first showing in Germany was on October 27 as part of the Leipzig Film Festival. The director Laura Poitras was present in Hamburg at the Abaton cinema for a preview on November 4–5 and at the official German premiere at the Kino International. Its widest release as of January 22, 2015, was 105 theaters, in the weekend of December 12–18, 2014.[31]

It premiered on Home Box Office on February 23, 2015, the day after the 87th Academy Awards[32] and was subsequently released for streaming on HBO Go.[33] Channel 4 broadcast it in the United Kingdom on February 25, 2015[34] and has released it for view-on-demand through March 4, 2015.[35]

Citizenfour received widespread critical acclaim. It has an approval rating of 96% on Rotten Tomatoes based on 145 reviews, with an average score of 8.26/10. The site's critics' consensus reads: "Part real-life thriller, part sobering examination of 21st century civil liberties, Citizenfour transcends ideology to offer riveting, must-see cinema."[36] Metacritic gave the film a score of 88 out of 100 based on 38 reviews, indicating "universal acclaim".[37]

Ronnie Scheib of Variety wrote:

No amount of familiarity with whistleblower Edward Snowden and his shocking revelations of the U.S. government's wholesale spying on its own citizens can prepare one for the impact of Laura Poitras's extraordinary documentary Citizenfour... far from reconstructing or analyzing a fait accompli, the film tersely records the deed in real time, as Poitras and fellow journalist Glenn Greenwald meet Snowden over an eight-day period in a Hong Kong hotel room to plot how and when they will unleash the bombshell that shook the world. Adapting the cold language of data encryption to recount a dramatic saga of abuse of power and justified paranoia, Poitras brilliantly demonstrates that information is a weapon that cuts both ways.[38]

Spencer Ackerman writes in The Guardian:

Citizenfour must have been a maddening documentary to film. Its subject is pervasive global surveillance, an enveloping digital act that spreads without visibility, so its scenes unfold in courtrooms, hearing chambers and hotels. Yet the virtuosity of Laura Poitras, its director and architect, makes its 114 minutes crackle with the nervous energy of revelation.[39]

Time magazine rated the film #3 out of its top 10 movies of 2014[40] and called the film "This Halloween's Scariest Chiller".[41] Vanity Fair rated it #4 out of its top 10[42] and Grantland rated it #3 of its top 10.[43] Writing for the Chicago Tribune, former Defense Department intelligence analyst Alex Lyda penned a negative review, calling Snowden "more narcissist than patriot".[44] David Edelstein reviewed the film mostly favorably, and jocularly advised viewers "don't buy your ticket online or with a credit card".[45]

The film site Fandor has published an extensive survey of other articles and reviews about Citizenfour, updated through December 25, 2014.[46]

Movie's impact

On Sept. 18, 2018, it was ruled by the European Court of Human Rights that the U.K. spy agency's bulk collection of telecom data violated the European Convention on Human Rights. The Strasburg-based court ruled 5-2 that the practice "failed to safeguard rights to privacy guaranteed under the human rights convention". The complaint was brought on by ten groups including the ACLU, Privacy International, Amnesty International and other civil liberties groups around the world.[47][48][49]

In December 2014, retired naval officer and oil executive Horace Edwards of Kansas filed suit against the film's producers "on behalf of the American people" for aiding and abetting Snowden's leaks.[50][51] The Hollywood Reporter provided some legal analysis, noting observers opining that Edwards may not have legal standing to pursue the lawsuit.[52] Edwards also challenged the film's Oscar eligibility on the grounds that Poitras's 2013 short film showing Greenwald interviewing Snowden constituted a previous release of Citizenfour, rendering it ineligible under Oscar rules. The Academy rejected the claim, noting that "The Guardian interview appears in less than two minutes of the documentary", and ruled that Citizenfour was eligible for Oscar consideration.[53]

In February 2015, the filmmakers asked the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas to dismiss the lawsuit on standing and jurisdictional grounds, and on First Amendment grounds citing Bartnicki v. Vopper.[54] Edwards officially dropped the case on April 3, 2015.[55][56]

At DOK Leipzig 2014, when Citizenfour won the Leipziger Ring award, Edward Snowden gave a video message to the festival.[65]

Citizenfour won the 2015 Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature.[66] It was considered the frontrunner heading into the awards;[67][68][69] Brent Lang of Variety called for Citizenfour to receive a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Picture,[70] with THR's Gregg Kilday discussing its prospects,[71] but it was not nominated in that category.

Poitras also received several journalistic and humanitarian awards for reporting the Snowden disclosures depicted in the film, including the George Polk award (with Greenwald and MacAskill),[72] the Ridenhour Truth-Telling Prize (with Edward Snowden)[73] the Carl von Ossietzky Medal for human rights (with Greenwald and Snowden),[74] and the Henri Nannen Prize for Efforts for Independence of the Press.[75] The Guardian and The Washington Post received the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service for reporting by Poitras, Greenwald, MacAskill, and Barton Gellman.[76]

• List of films featuring surveillance
• Previous films in trilogy: My Country, My Country (2006) and The Oath (2010)
• No Place to Hide, book by Glenn Greenwald about the Snowden disclosures, including the events depicted in the film
• Snowden, a film directed by Oliver Stone and starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt that depicts parts of the production of Citizenfour

1. ^ "Citizenfour (2014) - Financial Information". The Numbers. Retrieved March 7, 2021.
2. ^ "CITIZENFOUR (15)". British Board of Film Classification. October 17, 2014. Retrieved August 8, 2015.
3. ^ "Citizen Four (2004)". The Wrap. July 13, 2015. Archived from the original on March 13, 2017. Retrieved March 12, 2017.
4. ^ "Citizenfour (2014)". Box Office Mojo. Retrieved February 24, 2015.
5. ^ Greenberg, Andy (October 13, 2014), "These Are the Emails Snowden Sent to First Introduce His Epic NSA Leaks", Wired
6. ^ "The Woman Who Captured Snowden". www.vice.com. October 20, 2014. Retrieved November 13, 2022.
7. ^ Suzanna Andrews; Bryan Burrough; Sarah Ellison (May 2014), "The Snowden Saga: A Shadowland of Secrets and Light", Vanity Fair
8. ^ Thomas Keenan, “Windows: of Vulnerability,” Ed. Bruce Robbins, The Phantom Public Sphere (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press,1997), 121-141
9. ^ Chumley, Cheryl; Sherfinski, David. "Edward Snowden granted asylum in Russia, leaves airport". The Washington Times. Retrieved April 21, 2015.
10. ^ "Edward Snowden". Biography. Retrieved October 1, 2018.
11. ^ Executive Summary of Review of the Unauthorized Disclosures of Former National Security Agency Contractor Edward Snowden. Washington, D.C.: U.S. House of Representatives. 2016.
12. ^ Harding, Luke (February 1, 2014). "How Edward Snowden went from loyal NSA contractor to whistleblower". the Guardian. Retrieved October 8, 2018.
13. ^ "Edward Snowden: A Timeline - NBC News". NBC News. Retrieved October 8, 2018.
14. ^ Snowden, Edward J. (2019). Permanent Record. New York: Henry Holt & Co. pp. 150, 277.
15. ^ "Edward Snowden says motive behind leaks was to expose 'surveillance state'". The Washington Post. Retrieved October 20, 2018.
16. ^ "Edward Snowden Speaks Out: 'I Haven't And I Won't' Cooperate With Russia". NPR.org. Retrieved February 13, 2020.
17. ^ "After 6 Years in Exile, Edward Snowden Explains Himself". Wired. ISSN 1059-1028. Retrieved February 13, 2020.
18. ^ a b Packer, George (October 20, 2014). "Laura Poitras's closeup view of Edward Snowden". The New Yorker. Retrieved December 12, 2014.
19. ^ Lapin, Andrew (October 24, 2014). "'Citizenfour' Follows The Snowden Story Without (Much) Grandstanding". NPR. Retrieved December 12, 2014.
20. ^ Greenwald, Glenn, "Excerpt: Glenn Greenwald's 'No Place to Hide'", ABC News, archived from the original on May 29, 2014
21. ^ Lang, Brent (October 26, 2014). "Radius-TWC Chief on 'Citizenfour': 'It's Going to Get Heated'". Variety. Retrieved December 12, 2014.
22. ^ Frater, Patrick (September 17, 2014). "Edward Snowden Documentary 'Citizenfour' Added to London Festival Lineup". Variety. Retrieved December 12, 2014.
23. ^ a b c Maass, Peter (August 13, 2013), "How Laura Poitras Helped Snowden Spill His Secrets", The New York Times
24. ^ Cadwalladr, Carole (November 9, 2014), "Berlin's digital exiles: where tech activists go to escape the NSA", The Guardian
25. ^ a b Greenberg, Andy (October 15, 2014), "Laura Poitras on the Crypto Tools That Made Her Snowden Film Possible", Wired
26. ^ Macaulay, Scott (October 20, 2014), "Positive Trauma: Editor Mathilde Bonnefoy on CITIZENFOUR", Filmmaker magazine
27. ^ a b Hernandez, Eugene (October 14, 2014), Silent No More, Laura Poitras Talks About 'CITIZENFOUR', Film Society of Lincoln Center
28. ^ Feinberg, Scott (September 16, 2014), "New York Film Fest: Top-Secret Edward Snowden Doc Added to Lineup", The Hollywood Reporter
29. ^ Higgins, Parker (October 29, 2014), The 7 Privacy Tools Essential to Making Snowden Documentary CITIZENFOUR, Electronic Frontier Foundation
30. ^ "This is what a Tor Supporter looks like: Laura Poitras".
31. ^ Citizenfour, Box Office Mojo
32. ^ Andreeva, Nellie (January 8, 2015), Edward Snowden Docu 'CitizenFour' To Debut On HBO Right After Oscars, deadline.com
33. ^ Armstrong, Olivia (February 24, 2015), Oscar Winning Edward Snowden Documentary 'Citizenfour' Is Now On HBO Go, Decider
34. ^ Mullin, Joe (February 23, 2015), PSA: Oscar-winning Citizenfour to air on HBO today
35. ^ Citizenfour, Channel 4, archived from the original on February 28, 2015, retrieved February 28, 2015
36. ^ "Citizenfour (2014)". Rotten Tomatoes. Fandango Media. Retrieved July 17, 2019.
37. ^ "Citizenfour Reviews". Metacritic. CBS Interactive. Retrieved June 30, 2016.
38. ^ Scheib, Ronnie (October 11, 2014), "Film Review: 'Citizenfour'", Variety
39. ^ Ackerman, Spencer (October 11, 2014). "Citizenfour Review – Poitras' Victorious Film Shows Snowden Vindicated". The Guardian. Retrieved October 11, 2014.
40. ^ Richard Corliss (December 2, 2014), "Top 10 Best Movies", Time magazine
41. ^ Corliss, Richard (October 26, 2014), "Review: Citizenfour Is This Halloween's Scariest Chiller", Time
42. ^ Lawson, Richard (December 8, 2014), "The 10 Best Movies of 2014", Vanity Fair
43. ^ Wesley Morris (December 18, 2014), The Top 10 Movies of 2014, Grantland
44. ^ Lyda, Alex (December 23, 2014), "Edward Snowden is more narcissist than patriot", Chicago Tribune
45. ^ David Edelstein (October 24, 2014), The Edward Snowden Documentary Citizenfour Puts You Right in the Room As History Is Made, vulture.com
46. ^ Hudson, David (October 12, 2014), NYFF 2014 - Laura Poitras's Citizenfour, Fandor, archived from the original on February 7, 2015, retrieved January 26, 2015
47. ^ Melendez, Steven (September 13, 2018). "Court: U.K. spy program revealed in Edward Snowden leaks violated human rights". Fast Company. Retrieved April 22, 2019.
48. ^ "Q&A: European Court of Human Rights Rules UK Mass Surveillance Laws Violate Rights". Privacy International. Retrieved July 18, 2019.
49. ^ "Top European Court Says British Spies Broke Human Rights Rules With Their Mass Surveillance Tactics". Fortune. Retrieved July 18, 2019.
50. ^ Gardner, Eriq (December 22, 2014), "Citizenfour Producers Sued Over Edward Snowden Leaks", The Hollywood Reporter
51. ^ Wingerter, Justin (December 31, 2014), "Topeka man, 89, files suit against Edward Snowden, documentary producers", The Topeka Capital-Journal
52. ^ Gardner, Eriq (January 14, 2015), "Man Suing Over Citizenfour Looks to Drag U.S. Into Edward Snowden Leaks Lawsuit", The Hollywood Reporter
53. ^ Feinberg, Scott (December 23, 2014), "Academy Rejects Challenge to Citizenfour Oscar Eligibility", The Hollywood Reporter
54. ^ Gardner, Eriq (February 11, 2015), "'Citizenfour' Filmmakers Demand End to Lawsuit Over Edward Snowden Disclosures", The Hollywood Reporter
55. ^ Kansan Drops Suit Over Oscar-Winning Snowden Doc, Courthouse News Service, May 7, 2015
56. ^ Notice of Dismissal (PDF), Court filing, April 3, 2015
57. ^ Film Prize 'LEIPZIGER RING', DOK Leipzig, November 1, 2014, archived from the original on January 28, 2015
58. ^ 30th Annual IDA Documentary Awards Winners, May 15, 2014
59. ^ Lewis, Hilary (January 7, 2015), "'Citizenfour' Wins Four Awards at Cinema Eye Honors", The Hollywood Reporter
60. ^ McNary, Dave (February 7, 2015), "DGA Awards: 'Birdman' Wins Best Feature Film for Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu", Variety
61. ^ "Film in 2015". bafta.org. BAFTA. n.d. Retrieved February 22, 2015.
62. ^ "The 87th Academy Awards". Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. Retrieved January 15, 2015.
63. ^ "Die Preisträger des deutschen Filmpreises 2015 (German)" (PDF). deutscher-filmpreis.de. Archived from the original (PDF) on June 20, 2015. Retrieved June 20, 2015.
64. ^ "Citizenfour". Academy of Television Arts & Sciences. Retrieved September 13, 2015.
65. ^ Snowden honors the peaceful revolution in Leipzig, DOK Leipzig, October 28, 2014
66. ^ "The 87th Academy Awards". Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. Retrieved February 22, 2015.
67. ^ Feinberg, Scott (October 10, 2014), "New York Film Fest: 'Citizenfour' Hacks Way to Top of Uber-Competitive Doc Oscar Race", The Hollywood Reporter
68. ^ Ben Beaumont-Thomas (January 15, 2015), "Oscars 2015: Edward Snowden film Citizenfour leads pack in Oscar documentary category", The Guardian
69. ^ Oscars – Best Documentary Feature Betting Odds, Oddschecker.com, retrieved January 24, 2015 reports Citizenfour as a 3:13 favourite according to online bookmakers.
70. ^ Lang, Brent (November 19, 2014), Why 'Citizenfour' Deserves a Best Picture Oscar Nomination
71. ^ "Oscars: Can Edward Snowden Doc 'Citizenfour' Break the Best-Picture Curse?", The Hollywood Reporter, December 3, 2014
72. ^ "2013 GEORGE POLK AWARD WINNERS". Long Island University. Retrieved March 2, 2014.
73. ^ Ridenhour Prizes. "The Ridenhour Prizes – Fostering the spirit of courage and truth". Ridenhour.org. Archived from the original on February 26, 2015. Retrieved October 22, 2014.
74. ^ English Material: Invitation for the Ceremonial act Carl-von-Ossietzky-Medal 2014, Berlin: Internationale Liga für Menschenrechte (International league for human rights), December 10, 2014
75. ^ "Henri Nannen Award for Efforts for Independence of the Press". Bertelsmann.com. Bertelsmann. May 8, 2014. Archived from the original on September 23, 2015. Retrieved June 7, 2014.
76. ^ "Guardian and Washington Post win Pulitzer prize for NSA revelations". The Guardian (Press release). April 14, 2014. Retrieved October 22, 2014.

• Official website
• Citizenfour at IMDb
• Citizenfour at Box Office Mojo
• Citizenfour at Rotten Tomatoes
• Citizenfour at Metacritic
• Citizenfour at AllMovie
• Citizenfour is available for free viewing and download at the Internet Archive